Wikia

Halo Fanon

Talk:Good Articles/Nomination

15,761pages on
this wiki

Back to page | < Halo Fanon talk:Good Articles

Archive 1
Archive 2
Archive 3
Archive 4

How-to

Nominations MUST follow every requirement set forth in this section HERE, refusal to do so will result in your nomination being removed from consideration. To submit an article for candidacy in the Good Articles project, please use the format seen below:

===[[ARTICLE NAME]]===
*'''Writer —''' {{Name|USERNAME}}
*'''Nominator —''' {{Name|USERNAME}}
*'''Date of Creation —''' Month Day, Year
*'''Date of Nomination —''' Month Day, Year
*'''Description —''' Describe the Good Article candidate in an effective way with as few words as possible.
*'''Why —''' In your opinion, why should this article be granted the honor of Good Article status?
*'''Status —''' The present status of the article as a Good Article candidate (FOR JUDICIARY PURPOSES ONLY!)

====Voting====

====Comments====

Nominations

Davenport Security Services, Inc.

  • Writer — FightWithHonor
  • Nominator — Lordofmonsterisland
  • Date of Creation — December 31, 2008
  • Date of Nomination — July 25, 2014
  • Description — A PMC founded at the turn of the 25th century, detailing their activities through the next century and a half as they survived two wars and dealt with the fallout.
  • Why — It's always been said that we lack a lot of the old articles in the GA category, so when I stumbled across this during the clean-up project I figured I'd throw it out there. We only have a few good corporation articles on the site, this potentially being one of them, so I believe it would add a little to the diversity.
  • Status — Nomination failed.

Voting

  1. Oppose Oppose — I would almost be in support of this, but there's just a few too many little things adding up that hold it back for me yet. For one, I'd remove that introduction header so the intro sits above the Table of Contents like it should, and it needs at least one more image to meet requirements, and while it just barely squeezes over the minimum length threshold, I'd feel a lot more comfortable supporting it if there was a bit more content. If that last point was the only thing holding it back, however, I'd be fine supporting it, as the article's grammar and spelling all seems to be up to par. A few missed s's and a period in one of the quotes, but if someone could get ahold of FWH after so long, I think it'd be a worthy addition to the GA ranks. That Damn Sniper 01:03, July 26, 2014 (UTC)
  2. Oppose Oppose — I agree. There are a few easily-fixed problems that could really improve the quality of this article, but at this point it needs some work to qualify for GA. Your friendly neighbourhood Halo Man
  3. Oppose Oppose — Lack of an introduction means it's inadmissable for GA, which is a shame, because it is a good article, while not meeting the standards required by this panel. I doubt there's much chance of FWH returning but should he do so, a little effort and this can gain Good Article status that it deserves. Swarm War Icon2 Athena32 - talk | contribs | email | articles

Comments

Kafkian Uprising

  • Writer — Chakravartin
  • Nominator — Ahalosniper
  • Date of Creation — December 1st, 2013
  • Date of Nomination — July 26th, 2014
  • Description — An event article detailing the causes and course of an uprising on a colony after the Human-Covenant War's end.
  • Why — The article is incredibly thorough in explaining the background and causes of the uprising. Factors from the colony's place in the UEG to corruption in the colonial government conspire to make the rebellion, when it breaks out, seem as though it were an inevitability.
  • Status — Pending

Voting

  1. Support Support — There are still a couple things I'd like to see, mainly a proofread by the author because there were some places I wasn't sure enough about when I went over it to be confident in changing, but the eye-catching unusual format, amount of content, and use of images puts it at the GA level for me already. That Damn Sniper 04:09, July 27, 2014 (UTC)
  2. Support Support — As per Ahalosniper. A great article overall that I've read through a couple of times in the past. Your friendly neighbourhood Halo Man
  3. Support Support — Chak has gone to obvious and extreme effort to make this fanon event as believable and detailed as possible, and it really shows, exhibiting detail you'd expect of a real-life event and not cutting corners when it comes to explaining why each faction does what it does. A personal favourite of mine and definitely deserving of GA recognition. Swarm War Icon2 Athena32 - talk | contribs | email | articles

Comments

Colin-142

  • Writer — Lieutenant Davis
  • Nominator — Ahalosniper
  • Date of Creation — Month Day, Year
  • Date of Nomination — July 26th, 2014
  • Description — One of the newer generation of SPARTAN-II flagships.
  • Why — There are some points in the article which could be improved, such as seemingly contradictory personality traits in the introduction, but Davis has incorporated plenty of media (some custom-edited), been careful about his spelling and grammar, and as a result of collaborating with other users has had to be very mindful of canon, creating an article that abides by the rules of the Halo universe.
  • Status — Pending

Voting

  1. Support Support — As per nomination. That Damn Sniper 04:09, July 27, 2014 (UTC)
  2. Support Support — There's been a great deal of hard work and effort put into creating this character since it was made. This greenish-blue Spartan is a good choice for GA. Your friendly neighbourhood Halo Man

====Comments====

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki